Underlying Conditions

India’s coronavirus crisis was decades in the making

23 March 2020
A woman pauses at Delhi’s government-run Safdarjung Hospital amid a growing outbreak of COVID-19. Private healthcare has boomed while public health facilities have been neglected for decades, leaving India ill-equipped to handle the COVID-19 pandemic.
Biplov Bhuyan / Hindustan Times / Getty Images
A woman pauses at Delhi’s government-run Safdarjung Hospital amid a growing outbreak of COVID-19. Private healthcare has boomed while public health facilities have been neglected for decades, leaving India ill-equipped to handle the COVID-19 pandemic.
Biplov Bhuyan / Hindustan Times / Getty Images

The global coronavirus crisis has been called many things: a pandemic, an unprecedented crisis, a re-run of sorts of the Spanish flu’s decimation of the human population just over a century ago. In India, from the eyes of anyone who studies public health, it is also a catastrophe that has been in the making for decades, perhaps since as far back as Independence. 

In weeks of reporting since India saw its first COVID-19 cases and deaths, I am yet to speak with an epidemiologist or infectious-disease expert who is surprised that the country is utterly unprepared for what awaits us—which, they all agree, is a surge of infections and resulting deaths. 

One assessment published in a medical journal in January reckoned that India had 2.3 ICU beds per 100,000 people. The medical system in Iran, for which the assessment put the figure at 4.6, is overwhelmed with COVID-19 cases. Experts in the United States, where the ratio of ICU beds was reckoned to be more than six times higher, are warning that it will soon run out of ICU beds too. India has less than one allopathic doctor per thousand people—the minimum recommended by the World Health Organisation. As of 2016, the Indian Medical Association was showing a shortage of tens of thousands of critical-care specialists. The dominant share of doctors and beds are in the private healthcare sector, which has enormous leeway to set its own prices and make its own rules—and to exploit both to put profits before patients. 

The government’s response has been characteristic of the Narendra Modi administration: lacking in transparency, and prioritising PR over public need. The health ministry, which has performed woefully few tests for the virus, maintained for unreasonably long that India only had cases of “imported” infection, contracted beyond international borders, and tailored its response accordingly. While other countries showed the value of aggressively tracing, isolating and testing anyone likely to have been exposed, our officials stuck by the line that India had no “community” transmission—a view based, as one doctor pointed out, on an absence of evidence rather than any evidence of absence. Modi’s speech to the nation on 19 March drummed up voluntary self-isolation, but said next to nothing about the government’s strategy to contain the effects of COVID-19, whether on the medical or the economic front. The AYUSH ministry endorsed a supposed homeopathic prophylactic to combat the virus. Some Hindu groups, and at least one BJP activist, have held “parties” to drink cow urine, their preferred anti-viral. 

Epidemics are a product of ignorance as well as disease. The coronavirus might be new, but the ignorance has been with us all along. Modi, his ministers and his party have held intellectuals and experts in disdain, and shown contempt for scientific thinking. A broken public education system is fuel to the fire. Allied to the ignorance is a willingness to look away—from the state of Indian healthcare, from the apathy of government after government, from the sicknesses already ravaging the population—even among those who should know better. Nothing brings this out better than our existing epidemic of tuberculosis. 

Vidya Krishnan is a health journalist based in Goa. Her first book, on the rise of antibiotic resistance and the threat to global health security, is slated to be published in 2020.

Keywords: COVID-19 Ministry of Health and Family Welfare public health
COMMENT