Crossing the Line

The NRC’s threat to Bangladesh, and the India–Bangladesh relationship

01 September 2019
Halima Khatun poses with her election card in Darrang, Assam. Her 17-year old daughter committed suicide after discovering that her name was not included in the NRC list.
ZISHAAN A LATIF FOR THE CARAVAN
Halima Khatun poses with her election card in Darrang, Assam. Her 17-year old daughter committed suicide after discovering that her name was not included in the NRC list.
ZISHAAN A LATIF FOR THE CARAVAN

“While we should not be worried, there is some anxiety after reading news reports,” AK Abdul Momen, the foreign minister of Bangladesh, told a television channel in July. He was speaking of the National Register of Citizens, the Indian government’s project to define and identify legal residents of the state of Assam—and, more importantly, to identify and make stateless those who it claims are illegal immigrants. Last year, the NRC provisionally identified around four million supposedly “illegal” people—almost exclusively Muslims—who in the official Indian narrative have been branded “Bengali” infiltrators, from across the border in Bangladesh. Momen’s cautious statement was reported as the first public admission of concern over the NRC by the Bangladesh government. Those the NRC had singled out, he said, had been living in Assam for over 75 years. “They are their citizens,” he insisted, “not ours.”

India has not said what it plans to do with those the NRC tags as outsiders and renders stateless. But in Bangladesh, few have any doubts as to what the eventual goal is—and many raise warnings in sharper terms than Momen did. Shaheen Afroze, a research director at a think tank under the country’s foreign ministry, told me that the Assamese Muslims targeted by the NRC “are not only an internal issue of India anymore, because their intended eviction destination is Bangladesh.”

Bangladesh has seen this tragic charade before—across its other international border, with Buddhist-majority Myanmar. There too, a Muslim people, the Rohingya, are considered illegal though they have lived in the country for many generations. There too, they are being pushed out to further narrow domestic political ends, and are portrayed as “Bangladeshis.” Since 2017 alone, three quarters of a million Rohingyas have been pushed out of Myanmar by force.

Don't want to read further? Stay in touch

  • Free newsletters. updates. and special reads
  • Be the first to hear about subscription sales
  • Register for Free

    Afsan Chowdhury is a journalist and research scholar based in Dhaka.

    Keywords: NRC Bangladesh Awami League Sheikh Hasina Indo-Bangladesh border Narendra Modi
    COMMENT